Cookies 'n Cream
Avoid
Score range: Below 6.0
A low Creami score doesn't mean a bad protein powder — it's judged specifically for Ninja Creami ice cream. See FAQ →
This powder didn't work well in the Ninja Creami. Texture or flavor didn't hold up in the frozen base — but that doesn't mean it's a bad powder overall. See the note below.
The Review
The Clean Simple Eats Cookies 'n Cream protein powder delivered a commendable texture when prepared in the Ninja Creami. The resulting pint was consistently smooth and free from any undesirable icy bits, which is a positive attribute for Creami users. This suggests the powder mixes well and contributes to a good mouthfeel.
However, the flavor experience was a notable letdown ... a significant let down. The taste was far from the classic dessert it aims to emulate. The artificiality of the flavor was prominent, making it difficult to enjoy the pint. This particular flavor did not blend well into a frozen dessert, resulting in an unappetizing final product that was challenging to finish.
Score Breakdown
Flavor accuracy, no off-notes
Creaminess, scoop-ability
Protein-to-calorie efficiency
Xylitol, Organic Stevia Extract (Reb A), Reb M (as OnoSweet)
+ Recipe adds erythritol (from the recipe, not this powder).
About sweeteners →How It's Scored
Macros Per Pint
12g protein / 100 calTested with The Standard Recipe.
Full Pint Nutrition Facts
Per Full Pint (pure — no Oreos)
Natural
Calculated from the powder's nutrition label + The Standard Recipe baseline (375g Fairlife 2%, 1 tbsp erythritol, 2 tsp non-fat milk powder, 1/8 tsp vanilla extract, 1/8 tsp xanthan gum, 1/2 tsp glycerin).
More Cookies & Cream Powders
See all Cookies & Cream powders →
About This Brand
Clean Simple Eats — #4 Brand · 5.1 avg
Clean Simple Eats gets a lot of hype, but the results don’t really back it up. Across the sampler, most flavors come out muted and one-note, lacking the punch you want in a Creami pint. Mint Chocolate Cookie is the only real standout, but even that falls short of being something you’d crave—this isn’t a brand worth prioritizing.
Community Reviews
1 reviewWould never buy this powder for the taste. Macro friendly only.
Tried this powder?
Log in to leave a rating and comment. Your experience helps others find their next great pint.
Log in to ReviewHaving texture issues? Icy pints, flat flavor, or grainy texture are almost always fixable.
See the fix guide →This page may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through a link, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate relationships have no influence on scores.