A decent option for Ninja Creami protein ice cream. Works well enough, but there are better choices in the rankings. Decent option if it's on sale.
The Review
This powder delivers a reliably good texture, spinning up dense and creamy on the first pass without needing a re-spin. It's consistent and holds up well in the freezer, avoiding the common pitfalls of iciness or gumminess that plague many protein ice creams. This makes it a solid base for mix-ins, as it provides a neutral canvas that won't detract from added flavors or textures.
However, the flavor profile itself is somewhat muted and unremarkable. It's not offensive, but it lacks the vibrancy or distinctiveness that elevates a protein ice cream from "just okay" to genuinely enjoyable. While it's a perfectly solid option for hitting macros, there are definitely better-tasting powders out there that offer a more exciting pint experience.
Score Breakdown
Flavor accuracy, no off-notes
Creaminess, scoop-ability
Protein-to-calorie efficiency
Glucosylated Stevia Extract (Leaf), OnoSweet Fermented Reb M
+ Recipe adds erythritol (from the recipe, not this powder).
About sweeteners →How It's Scored
Macros Per Pint
13.2g protein / 100 calTested with The Standard Recipe.
Full Pint Nutrition Facts
Per Full Pint (pure — no Oreos)
Natural
Calculated from the powder's nutrition label + The Standard Recipe baseline (375g Fairlife 2%, 1 tbsp erythritol, 2 tsp non-fat milk powder, 1/8 tsp vanilla extract, 1/8 tsp xanthan gum, 1/2 tsp glycerin).
More Cookies & Cream Powders
See all Cookies & Cream powders →
About This Brand
ProDough — #3 Brand · 6.0 avg
Prodough has a massive flavor lineup, but the results are inconsistent. A few standouts like Coconut Cream and Raspberry Cheesecake score in the 9s, but the majority land in the lower range with flavor issues, especially baked goods or spiced flavors. If you want to try Prodough, stick to the top-rated flavors and skip the rest.
Community Reviews
No community reviews yet — be the first to share your experience!
Tried this powder?
Log in to leave a rating and comment. Your experience helps others find their next great pint.
Log in to ReviewHaving texture issues? Icy pints, flat flavor, or grainy texture are almost always fixable.
See the fix guide →This page may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through a link, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate relationships have no influence on scores.