The Pint Lab
Top 10 Protein Powders
for Ninja Creami
Every powder on this list was tested using the same recipe, the same machine, and the same honest scoring process. Scores are for the frozen pint — not a shake. This chart updates automatically as new powders are tested.
Score out of 10
The Full Top 10 List
Levels
Vanilla Bean
FlavCity
Butter Coffee
FlavCity
Mint Chocolate
Prodough
Coconut Cream
Levels
Cappuccino
FlavCity
Cookies & Cream
FlavCity
Salted Caramel
ProDough
Raspberry Cheesecake
FlavCity
Banana Bread
Levels
Chocolate Mocha
How We Score
Every powder is tested using the same base recipe — one scoop, 375g Fairlife 2% milk, erythritol, non-fat milk powder, vanilla extract, and xanthan gum — spun in a Ninja Creami on the Ice Cream setting. Scores reflect texture, flavor, creaminess, and macro efficiency in the frozen pint, not a shake. Scores range from 6.0 (Solid) to 9.0+ (Elite). Anything below 6.0 is listed in our Avoid section.
See all 37 powders we've tested
View Full Rankings →