The Pint Lab · Tested & Ranked
Best Protein Powders at Trader Joe's for the Ninja Creami
Trader Joe's carries a small but well-curated selection of protein powders — typically cleaner labels, reasonable prices, and a few surprises. The selection is more limited than big-box stores, but if you're already doing your weekly TJ's run, it's worth knowing which powders actually work in the Ninja Creami. We tested everything we could find using our standard base recipe and ranked them by taste, texture, and macros.
See how every powder ranks
Filter by flavor, sort by score, calories, or protein — all 50+ powders tested with the same recipe.
The Best Protein Powders at Trader Joe's for Ninja Creami
Coming Soon
Review in progressThese powders are available at Trader Joe's and are currently being tested. Scores will be published once testing is complete.
How We Test
Every powder on this list has been tested using the same base recipe — one scoop, 375g Fairlife 2% milk, erythritol, non-fat milk powder, vanilla extract, and xanthan gum — spun in a Ninja Creami on the Ice Cream setting. Scores reflect taste (35%), texture (35%), macro efficiency (15%), and whether we'd buy a full tub (15%). Rankings update automatically as new powders are tested.
Frequently Asked Questions
Want to see all 58+ powders we've tested?
Sort by score, calories, protein, or macros efficiency
View Full Rankings →